Is Elijah Craig Barrel Proof A124 Better than B524? Find Out Here!

7/6/2024

Elijah Craig Barrel Proof whiskeys are renowned for their powerful flavors and strong proof. Today, we compare two of their editions: A124 and B524. Is the new B524 superior, or does the A124 still hold strong? Let's find out!

The Contenders

A124

  • Proof: 119
  • Age: 10 years and 9 months
  • Color: Lighter amber
  • Flavor Notes:
    • Aroma: Barrel proof aroma
    • Taste: Creamy, with hints of tobacco, walnut, and a nutty finish
    • Mouthfeel: Sticks to the tongue

B524

  • Proof: 130
  • Age: 11 years and 2 months
  • Color: Darker amber; richer hue
  • Flavor Notes:
    • Aroma: Vanilla, apple wood, earthy and woody notes
    • Taste: Creamy with honey, cinnamon, subtle baking spices, oak, and a touch of leather
    • Mouthfeel: Chewy with a noticeable proof difference

Tasting Notes

Experience with A124

The A124 provides a solid barrel proof experience. Its aroma is inviting, and the taste is creamy. However, it has a recurring tobacco note and a nutty finish which some may not prefer. While it's a good whiskey, it didn't completely live up to the hype.

Experience with B524

The B524, with its higher proof, delivers a richer, more complex experience. Its aroma of vanilla and apple wood is more appealing. The taste is creamy with flavors of honey and cinnamon dominating. Unlike A124, it doesn’t have that lingering nutty finish but offers subtle tobacco and leather notes. Its higher proof doesn’t burn but enhances the richness.

Which Is Better?

If you're a fan of higher proof whiskeys, B524 might be the right choice for you. It is more complex, with richer flavors and aromas. The A124 is still a good option but lacks some depth and complexity compared to B524.

Conclusion

After this tasting challenge, B524 emerges as the victor. Its richer aromas, more complex flavors, and higher proof make it stand out. If you are looking for a sophisticated pour for your Friday nights, B524 is a strong contender.

What do you think? Have you tried these whiskeys? Let us know your experience!